MCMEG: Intercomparison exercise on prostate radiotherapy dose assessment

The improvement of the Monte Carlo (MC) community skills on computational simulations in Medical Physics is crucial to the field of radiotherapy as well as radiology. The Monte Carlo Modelling Expert Group (MCMEG) is an expert network specialized in MC radiation transport modelling and simulation applied to the radiation protection and dosimetry research fields. The MCMEG addressed a multigroup dosimetric intercomparison exercise for modelling and simulating a case of prostate radiation therapy (RT) protocol. This intercomparison was launched in order to obtain the dose distribution in the prostate target volume and in the neighboring organs. Dose assessments were achieved by using TLDs. A protocol using two pair of parallel-opposed fields were planned and performed with Alderson-Rando Pelvic Phantom. The assessed organs at risk were the urinary bladder, rectum and right and left femur heads. The RT simulations were performed using the MCNPx, MCNP6 and egs++ and BEAMnrc/DOSXYZnrc modules of EGSnrc Monte Carlo codes. The dose to the target volume, mean doses and standard deviation in the organs at risk, and dose volume data were computed. A comparison between the simulated results and the experimental values obtained from TLD measurements was made. In some cases the results obtained using MC simulations showed large deviations in comparison to the results obtained from the TLD measurements and these variations can be explained by the difficulties in the modelling of the geometry, selection of MC parameters required for the simulations and the statistical errors and inaccuracies in experimental measurements. Even though, the exercise has been a great opportunity for the MC groups to learn and share the main difficulties found during the modelling and the analysis of the results. Concerned to the obtained variations, the MCMEG team consider that this was expected for the level of complexity of the exercise and must be studied by the MC groups. •The Monte Carlo Modelling Expert Group (MCMEG).•Intercomparison exercise of dose assessments achieved with TLDs.•Simulations using the MCNPx, MCNP6 and EGSnrc and BEAMnrc/DOSXYZnrc MC codes.•MCMEG team consider that this was expected for the level of complexity of the exercise and must be studied by the MC groups.