Divergence between functional magnetic resonance imaging and clinical indicators of language dominance in preoperative language mapping

Accurate determination of hemispheric language dominance prior to epilepsy surgery is critically important to minimize cognitive morbidity. Functional MRI (fMRI) is a noninvasive method that is highly concordant with other clinical indicators of language laterality, and is now commonly used to confirm language dominance. However, there is also a high frequency of divergence between fMRI findings and other clinical indices that complicate determination of dominance and surgical decision‐making in individual patients. Despite this, divergent cases are rarely published or discussed. This article provides three illustrative examples to demonstrate common scenarios where fMRI may produce conflicting or otherwise difficult‐to‐interpret findings. We will also discuss potential reasons for divergence and propose a flow‐chart to aid clinical decision making in such situations. There is a high frequency of divergence between functional MRI (fMRI) findings and other indices of hemispheric language dominance that complicate clinical decision‐making in individual patients prior to neurosurgery. Despite this, divergent cases are rarely published or discussed. This article provides three illustrative examples to demonstrate common scenarios where fMRI may produce conflicting or otherwise difficult‐to‐interpret findings, and includes a flow‐chart to aid clinical decision making in such situations.