Effect of pilot hole on biomechanical and in vivo pedicle screw–bone interface

Purpose To experimentally study the influence of pilot hole diameter (smaller than or equal to the internal (core) diameter of the screw) on biomechanical (insertion torque and pullout strength) and histomorphometric parameters of screw–bone interface in the acute phase and 8 weeks after pedicle screw insertion. Methods Fifteen sheep were operated upon and pedicle screws inserted in the L1–L3 pedicles bilaterally. The pilot hole was smaller (2.0 mm) than the internal diameter (core) of the screw on the left side pedicle and equal (2.8 mm) to the internal diameter (core) of the screw on the right side pedicle. Ten animals were sacrificed immediately (five animals were assigned to pullout strength tests and five animals were used for histomorphometric bone–screw interface evaluation). Five animals were sacrificed 8 weeks after pedicle screw insertion for histomorphometric bone–screw interface evaluation. Results The insertion torque and pullout strength were significantly greater in pedicle screws inserted into pilot holes smaller than internal (core) diameter of the screw. Histomorphometric evaluation of bone–screw interface showed that the percentage of bone-implant contact, the area of bone inside the screw thread and the area of bone outside the screw thread were significantly higher for pilot holes smaller than the internal (core) diameter of the screw immediately after insertion and after 8 weeks. Conclusion A pilot diameter smaller than the internal (core) diameter of the screw improved the insertion torque and pullout strength immediately after screw insertion as well the pedicle screw–bone interface contact immediately and 8 weeks after screw placement in sheep with good bone mineral density.