Evaluating the C-section rate of different physician practices: using machine learning to model standard practice

The C-section rate of a population of 22,175 expectant mothers is 16.8%; yet the 17 physician groups that serve this population have vastly different group C-section rates, ranging from 13% to 23%. Our goal is to determine retrospectively if the variations in the observed rates can be attributed to variations in the intrinsic risk of the patient sub-populations (i.e. some groups contain more "high-risk C-section" patients), or differences in physician practice (i.e. some groups do more C-sections). We apply machine learning to this problem by training models to predict standard practice from retrospective data. We then use the models of standard practice to evaluate the C-section rate of each physician practice. Our results indicate that although there is variation in intrinsic risk among the groups, there also is much variation in physician practice.