Roles of Ferric Peroxide Anion Intermediates (Fe3+O2−, Compound 0) in Cytochrome P450 19A1 Steroid Aromatization and a Cytochrome P450 2B4 Secosteroid Oxidation Model

Cytochrome P450 (P450, CYP) 19A1 is the steroid aromatase, the enzyme responsible for the 3‐step conversion of androgens (androstenedione or testosterone) to estrogens. The final step is C−C bond scission (removing the 19‐oxo group as formic acid) that proceeds via a historically controversial reaction mechanism. The two competing mechanistic possibilities involve a ferric peroxide anion (Fe3+O2−, Compound 0) and a perferryl oxy species (FeO3+, Compound I). One approach to discern the role of each species in the reaction is with the use of oxygen‐18 labeling, i.e., from 18O2 and H218O of the reaction product formic acid. We applied this approach, using several technical improvements, to study the deformylation of 19‐oxo‐androstenedione by human P450 19A1 and of a model secosteroid, 3‐oxodecaline‐4‐ene‐10‐carboxaldehyde (ODEC), by rabbit P450 2B4. Both aldehyde substrates were sensitive to non‐enzymatic acid‐catalyzed deformylation, yielding 19‐norsteroids, and conditions were established to avoid issues with artifactual generation of formic acid. The Compound 0 reaction pathway predominated (i.e., Fe3+O2−) in both P450 19A1 oxidation of 19‐oxo‐androstenedione and P450 2B4 oxidation of ODEC. The P450 19A1 results contrast with our prior conclusions (J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2014, 136, 15016–16025), attributed to several technical modifications. Although most cytochrome P450‐catalyzed oxidations are believed to utilize perferryl oxygen (Compound I) as a reactive iron species, the ferric peroxide species (Compound 0) is thought to catalyze some oxidative deformylations. This study revealed the dominant contribution of Compound 0 in the P450 19A1‐catalyzed steroid aromatization and P450 2B4‐catalyzed model aromatization reactions, utilizing deuterium and 18O labeling approaches.