Outcome of Necrosectomy in Acute Pancreatitis: the Case for Continued Vigilance

Background: Surgery for pancreatic necrosis complicating acute severe pancreatitis carries a high risk of mortality and may be influenced by a range of variables including patterns of referral, case selection and quality of care. Methods: An observational study of a consecutive series of 54 patients undergoing pancreatic necrosectomy in a specialist Hepatobiliary unit over an 8-year study period. Principal outcomes were organ dysfunction and physiological derangement in relation to surgery, microbial colonization of necrosis and relation to outcome, re-operation rates, requirement for peri-operative nutritional support, trends in mortality and survival analysis. Results: Necrosectomy was associated with statistically significant deterioration in immediate postoperative organ dysfunction scores (ANOVA P < 0.01). Infected necrosis was present in 36 (68%). Fungal colonization of necrosis was present in 5 (9%). Mortality in this subgroup was 80% (4 deaths). There was no association between bacterial colonization of necrosis and death in this study ( P = 0.77; Fisher exact test; relative risk 0.9, 95% confidence interval 0.54-1.54). Twenty patients (37%) required further surgical intervention with an average of 1.5 surgical procedures per patient. Twenty-three patients (43%) died. Patient survival to discharge was best predicted by admission APACHE-II score with relative risk of death increasing 14% for each unit increase in APACHE-II score at admission. Conclusions: The results of the present study illustrate that there is no place for complacency in the surgical management of patients with severe acute pancreatitis. A clinical governance approach would promote pre-defined protocols between admitting hospitals and tertiary referral centres. Future research should target new interventions in patients with high admission APACHE-II scores in whom prognosis is particularly poor and explore the role of infection of necrotic tissue.