Catheter deadspace: a source of error during tonometry

Tonometry of PCO2 is a promising method for assessing the oxygen supply to demand ratio of the gastrointestinal mucosa in critically ill patients. A balloon-tipped tonometer is introduced into the stomach or sigmoid colon, and saline is instilled into the balloon. After a time to allow partial equilibration with intraluminal PCO2, saline is aspirated and PCO2 is measured. Intermittent instillation and aspiration of saline allows serial PCO2 measurements, provided correction factors are used to calculate the PCO2 value expected at full equilibration from the PCO2 values measured after short dwell times. The technique is not yet widely applied, partly because of methodological controversies. We evaluated the role of the catheter deadspace as a source of error during PCO2 tonometry. The increase in PCO2 in sigmoid-type tonometers with a normal length (normal tonometer (NT)) and in those with a 50% increase in length and thus deadspace (extended tonometer (ET)), in a saline bath at a PCO2 of 4.8 kPa was assessed. Saline dwell times were 10, 20, 30, 45, 60 and 90 min and the time-dependent PCO2 increase was determined at deadspace PCO2 values of approximately 4.0 and 8.0 kPa following contamination of the catheter deadspace after immersion in saline baths at PCO2 values of 4.8 and 9.6 kPa, respectively, before each measurement cycle. In another experiment, the tonometer was rinsed between measurement cycles to remove deadspace saline containing carbon dioxide and to obviate contamination of instilled saline. PCO2 was measured in a blood-gas analyser, taking into account measurement bias in saline. Failure to remove deadspace saline between measurement cycles resulted in an overestimation of 10% and 6% for the NT and 16% and 10% for the ET, at saline dwell times of 10 and 20 min, respectively, at a deadspace PCO2 of approximately 4.0 kPa. At a deadspace PCO2 of approximately 8.0 kPa, PCO2 was overestimated by 17%, 11% and 5% for the NT and 31%, 20% and 11% for the ET, at dwell times of 10, 20 and 30 min, respectively. Rinsing the NT/ET resulted in accurate assessment of PCO2 at all dwell times, but the dwell time-dependent increase in PCO2 was slightly slower in the ET, particularly at 10 min, after a sink effect of the increased deadspace. Hence, a previously unrecognized deadspace effect caused error during PCO2 tonometry, particularly with short dwell times. This potentially large error can be avoided by rinsing the tonometer before each measurement cycle, al