High performance liquid chromatography mobile phase composition optimization for the quantitative determination of a carboxylic acid compound in human plasma by negative ion electrospray high performance liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry

A systematic investigation was undertaken to study the effects of varying concentrations of additives in the acetonitrile/water high performance liquid chromatography mobile phase, especially formic acid and ammonium formate, on the negative ion electrospray response of a carboxylic acid compound. The study showed that the response progressively decreased with increase in the formic acid concentration. While such a decrease in the response could be qualitatively explained by the decrease in the concentration of the ionized form of the carboxylic acid compound due to the lower pH of the mobile phase, the change in response was not as large as expected from the change of the concentration of the ionized form. The response also progressively decreased with increase in the ammonium formate concentration but the decrease cannot be explained by the change in the pH of the mobile phase. Although the best negative ion electrospray response was obtained with a water/acetonitrile mobile phase that contained no additives at all, the retention time of the analyte was not found to be adequately reproducible on repeated injections. Thus, this mobile phase was deemed unacceptable for practical, routine use. Comparing formic acid against ammonium formate, the former was preferable since it caused a smaller attenuation of the negative ion response. Equally important was the fact that addition of formic acid had the desirable effect of maintaining a reasonably high capacity factor (k′) for the analyte even at a relatively high acetonitrile concentration. A concentration of 1 mM formic acid in the mobile phase was large enough to achieve the reproducible elongated retention time for the analyte, with a loss in the analyte response of about 60% only. It should be noted that the sensitivity achieved with the 1 mM formic acid mobile phase, in which the carboxylic acid is expected to be about 10% in the ionized form, is about 9 times better than the sensitivity achieved in the 1 mM ammonium formate mobile phase, in which the carboxylic acid is expected to be about 99% in the ionized form. © 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.