The relative value of glycated albumin, hemoglobin A1c and fructosamine when screening for diabetes mellitus

We compared the usefulness of three glycated serum proteins, glycated albumin (GA), glycated hemoglobin (HBA1c) and fructosamine (FA), for diabetic screening purposes. We measured these indices in 302 adults, most of whom underwent yearly physical examinations. We measured GA and HbA1c with high precision using high-performance liquid chromatography (interassay coefficients of variation 4.9 and 4.0%, respectively) and FA using commercial reagents (interassay coefficient of variation 1.65%). All the individuals underwent a 75-g oral glucose tolerance test, which revealed significant correlations between the values of the three glycated proteins and the four plasma glucose concentrations measured as well as the sum of these glucose concentrations, sigma BS (GA, r = 0.80; HbA1c, r = 0.80; FA, r = 0.65). On the basis of the test, 130 of the subjects were classified as normal (N), 123 as borderline and 49 as having diabetes mellitus (D) according to the criteria of the Japan Diabetes Society. Of the 123 borderline cases, 26 showed impaired glucose tolerance (IGT) according to the WHO criteria. The normal group values of GA, HbA1c and FA were 17.8 +/- 0.17% (mean +/- SEM), 5.02 +/- 0.03%, and 2.55 +/- 0.02 mM/l, respectively. Borderline and IGT subjects had significantly more GA and HbA1c than normal but not more FA (P less than 0.01). We divided the subjects into 10 groups on the basis of their sigma BS values; those with values higher than 671 +/- 4.7 mg/dl had significantly more GA and HbA1c than normal, while those with values higher than 1068 +/- 40.9 mg/dl (the most extreme cases) had significantly more FA.