Shift in the performance of 24-month-old Wistar rats in the Morris water escape task: a comparison across 36 experiments

Spatial discrimination learning in aged rats serves as an animal model of cognitive aging. We assessed the replicability of spatial discrimination performance in the standard Morris water escape task. To this end the learning curves and the performance in a probe trial of 24-month-old outbred Wistar (HsdWin:Wu) control rats from 36 experiments were compared. These experiments had been performed at our laboratory under strictly controlled conditions over a period of 71 weeks. There was a very high variability in the learning curves between experiments. The initial performance level, i.e. the performance during the first session, did not change systematically across the 36 experiments. In contrast, the final performance level, i.e. the level reached in the fifth training session, decreased over the 71 week period, when the platform escape latency and the distance swum to reach the platform, measured as number of line crossings, were considered. In the last experiments of the series, learning curves were no longer seen: the rats did not improve their performance across the acquisition sessions. By contrast, the swimming speed and, in the probe trial, the bias for the quadrant where the platform had been positioned during training, did not change. This indicates that a decrease across experiments occurred predominantly with respect to spatial orientation performance, whereas the motor performance appeared to be unchanged. Explanations for this observation, such as differences in viability between shipments and the possible occurrence of genetic drift, are discussed.