Laparoscopic evaluation for contralateral patent processus vaginalis: Part II

Between May 1, 1992 and August 1, 1995, 599 consecutively treated children under 10 years of age evaluated by the authors for a known inguinal hernia were involved in a prospective protocol to determine whether diagnostic laparoscopy has a place for evaluation of the contralateral inguinal region. The experience with the first 221 patients was reported at the 1993 AAP meeting. In this total experience, 81 patients had known bilateral inguinal hernias and did not require diagnostic laparoscopy. Five hundred eighteen patients had a unilateral inguinal hernia with the status of the contralateral region being unknown. Between May 1, 1992 and May 1, 1994, 368 children underwent evaluation using an umbilical approach. However, for the past 14 months, 150 patients have undergone the diagnostic laparoscopy through the ipsilateral hernia sac. Among the children under 1 year of age, 98 were found to have a unilateral hernia and also a contralateral patent processus vaginalis (CPPV) and 110 had a unilateral hernia. Of the children older than age 1, 116 had a unilateral hernia and CPPV and 194 had only a single hernia. After induction of anesthesia, it was suspected on clinical examination that 195 of the 518 patients had a CPPV. However, laparoscopy showed that only 94 (48%) had a CPPV. In the remaining 323 patients, the surgeon believed that a CPPV was not present based on the examination. This negative finding was verified in only 198 patients (61%), but a surprising 125 (39%) did have CPPV documented at the time of endoscopy. Insufflation alone was very unreliable for documenting the presence of CPPV. Of the 214 patients for whom CPPV on the contralateral side was documented during laparoscopy, only 41 (19%) had a positive finding on insufflation. This experience has convinced the authors that diagnostic laparoscopy is the most accurate means to ascertain whether a patient should undergo contralateral inguinal exploration. In addition, laparoscopy through the ipsilateral inguinal sac is now the preferred approach.