p53 Mediated tumor cell response to chemotherapeutic dna damage: A preliminary study in matched pairs of breast cancer biopsies

Wild type p53 plays a crucial role in maintaining genomic stability in both normal and tumor cells in vitro. When DNA damage occurs, p53 acts as a cell cycle checkpoint and induces a cellular response that aims at restoring genomic integrity. p53 may either allow the repair of damaged DNA by inducing a transient G1 arrest or may eliminate the damaged cells by triggering apoptosis. Mutant p53 fails to mediate any of these effects. From this, a p53 status-dependent response to therapy might be expected when tumors are treated with DNA-damaging genotoxic agents: Although wild type p53-harboring tumors have an intact checkpoint that might allow them to restore genomic integrity back to a pre-exposure level, mutant p53 tumors have a corrupted checkpoint that could lead to an accelerated loss of genomic stability. Until now, no studies have been described that examine such a p53-mediated effect in vivo. The authors tested this response model in vivo comparing 32 matched biopsy pairs from patients with breast cancer before and after rigorously standardized polychemotherapy. Four of the five drugs specifically induce a wild type p53-mediated checkpoint response. Tumor tissue from matched pairs of untreated and treated biopsies of the same patient were analyzed for treatment-associated changes of p53 protein expression by immunocytochemistry and, in a few available specimens, of p53 genotype changes by polymerase chain reaction-based DNA analysis. Treatment-associated changes of the p53 immunophenotype, which the authors speculate to reflect clonal selection, occurred in 39% (12 of 31) of the specimens. One specimen was not informative. Most tumors undergoing clonal selection originally harbored mutant p53 (nine of 12), and only three of 12 tumors were wild type. This study shows that exposure to genotoxic agents is commonly associated with a change in p53 immunophenotype. Although the limited material in this cohort prevented direct analysis of genetic instability, these results suggest that tumors with altered p53 may be genomically less stable and, therefore, may be more likely to undergo treatment-induced clonal changes than wild type tumors. This study also shows that the rigorous matched sample approach, although difficult to obtain, is an important tool that allows the in vivo assessment of the tumor response to genotoxic therapy in a controlled fashion.