Mechanics of Retrograde Nail Versus Plate Fixation for Supracondylar Femur Fractures

Two common types of internal fixations for the supracondylar femur fractures—the retrograde intramedullary nail and the 95° sideplate and screw—were mechanically tested in synthetic composite femur bones to determine the quantitative differences in their inherent rigidity. The medial and lateral femoral condyles were separated by a sagittal osteotomy, and a standardized medial segmental shaft defect was created at the distal shaft. The osteotomized specimens were stabilized using one of the two implants and were tested in different modes of loading. The bending stiffness of both constructs were not significantly different in varus compression, medial bending (pure varus), and bending in flexion. The plate and screw implant was three times stiffer in lateral bending (pure valgus) and 1.2 times stiffer in valgus compression than the retrograde supracondylar nail (p