Axial ranking of residues in collagen in relation to edge association and fibril formation

In our earlier analysis of intermolecular interactions between collagen molecules, a major concern with the program employed is that it compared numbers of interactions between residues located on edges of defined, identical width and thus would not necessarily compare the same number of residues in each edge. This would be particularly true of some values of θ where well‐defined vertical ranking of residues occurs. We have examined ranking of residues in relation to intermolecular edge association between bovine skin [α1(I)]3 model collagen molecules by utilizing two different methods of counting intermolecular interactions between residues. The interaction peaks at θ = 27.69° and 36.00° are absent or relatively less intense in the plots obtained by utilizing radial distances between interacting residues instead of vertical bands of defined width. These studies suggest caution in accepting recently reported analyses of superhelix coiling of the collagen molecule which point to values of 27.69° or 36.00° for the twist of the superhelix. Although intramolecular interactions clearly point to interaction of collagen molecules at D intervals, they are insufficiently restricted in distribution to provide a reliable estimate of the superhelix angle by procedures so far employed.