Rejection of islets versus immediately vascularized pancreatic allografts: A quantitative comparison

It has been suggested that free grafts of islets are rejected more vigorously than immediately vascularized intact organs grafts. However, the physiological manifestations of rejection depend, in part, upon the functional reserve of the transplanted tissue. If the number of islets transplanted is just adequate to maintain normoglycemia, the immune destruction of only a few islets will be manifested by hyperglycemia. Thus, differences in rejection time could be an artifact of the islet mass transplanted. We compared the onset of rejection of immediately vascularized segmental pancreatic grafts and of free grafts of islets under conditions in which the β cell mass transplanted, as determined by tissue insulin content, was equivalent. Lewis rats, made diabetic (plasma glucose > 400 mg/dl) by streptozotocin, received either free islet allografts by portal embolization or vascularized segmental pancreatic allografts derived from Fischer donors. Identical pancreatic segments that were not transplanted had a mean (± SE) total tissue insulin content of 33 ± 3 μg. The mean total insulin content of Fischer islets prepared by collagenase digestion in a quantity identical to that used for transplantation to single recipients was 35 ± 7 μg. Similar measurements were made in Fischer to Fischer and Lewis to Lewis isograft control groups. Recipients of both segmental pancreas and free islet grafts became normoglycemic after transplantation and this state was sustained indefinitely in recipients of syngeneic grafts. In rats receiving allografts, the day of rejection, defined as an elevation of plasma glucose to >200 mg/dl, occurred at a mean of 12.1 ± 0.3 days for recipients of pancreatic grafts ( n = 17) and 5.2 ± 0.3 days in recipients of islet grafts ( n = 17) ( P < 0.001). The functional survival of free grafts of allogeneic islets is less than that of islets contained within immediately vascularized pancreatic grafts, even when the transplanted β cell mass is equivalent. However, this difference could still be due to nonimmunologic, quantitative factors that influenced the rate with which hyperglycemia occurred after initiation of the rejection process. The insulin content in the livers of islet isograft recipients showed that only 53 to 71% of the transplanted islets survived. Further experiments that compensate for this factor are needed to determine whether or not there are differences in susceptibility to rejection of the two types of grafts. Nevertheless, on the