Invasion resistance on rocky shores: direct and indirect effects of three native predators on an exotic and a native prey species

Trophic relationships among native and exotic species produce novel direct and indirect interactions that can have wide-ranging community level effects and perhaps confer invasion resistance. We investigated whether native predators have the potential to directly limit the spread of the exotic musselMytilus galloprovincialisor mediate interactions among native and invasive mussels at a rocky intertidal invasion front in northern California. Lower survival ofM. galloprovincialisin transplanted cultures exposed to predators indicated that the invader was more vulnerable to predators than the numerically dominant nativeM. californianus. Survival and per capita mortality rate in monocultures and polycultures did not vary for eitherM. galloprovincialisorM. californianus, suggesting that predator-mediated apparent competition and associational defense did not occur. Complementary laboratory feeding trials determined which among 3 intertidal predators preferred the exotic to 2 native species of mussel. The whelkNucella ostrinawas most selective, consuming the thinner shelled mussels (M. galloprovincialisand the nativeM. trossulus) rather than the thicker-shelled native speciesM. californianus. The crabCancer antennariusand the sea starPisaster ochraceusshowed no preferences among mussel species.N. ostrinawere commonly observed among field-transplanted mussels; thus whelk predation may be especially important in limiting the establishment of the invasive mussel. However, 15% ofM. galloprovincialisremained intact in the field after 1 yr, suggesting that predation alone may not inhibit establishment of the invader. A tenuous balance between larval settlement and early post-settlement predation likely characterizes the invasion front.