Effect of Topical Sunscreens on the UV-Radiation–Induced Suppression of the Alloactivating Capacity in Human Skin In Vivo

Exposure of mice or humans to solar or artificial ultraviolet radiation (UV) has been shown to induce a number of changes in the immune system that may influence their susceptibility in skin tumors. The protective effect of sunscreens on these changes is not clear. Thirty-two patients with a variety of dermatoses routinely undergoing treatment with standard UVB (n = 19) or PUVA (n = 13) therapy were studied. One of two tested sunscreens or its vehicle was applied to the right flexor forearm immediately prior to each total-body UV exposure. Epidermal sheets were obtained by the suction-blister method from the left flexor forearm before treatment and from both flexor forearms after 4 weeks of photo- or photochemotherapy and used as stimulator epidermal cells (EC) in the mixed epidermal cell-lymphocyte reaction (MECLR). After 4 weeks of either UVB or PUVA therapy the MECLR responses on EC from both arms were markedly decreased. Neither the tested sunscreens nor their vehicles prevented the UV-induced suppression of the alloactivating capacity. The failure of sunscreens to protect against the UV-induced suppression of the alloactivating capacity could be explained in two ways. First, the energy not absorbed by the sunscreen could be sufficient to induce suppression of the alloactivating capacity. An alternative explanation could be systemic immune suppression by UV. In order to discriminate between these possibilities only the right forearms of 10 healthy volunteers, treated with a sunscreen or its vehicle, were irradiated with UVB during 4 weeks. In this manner systemic immune suppression by UVB could be excluded. This experiment resulted in a similar suppression of the MECLR responses, as induced by total body UVB irradiation, without any protection by the sunscreen. Apparently, the UV dose not absorbed by the sunscreen was capable to induce suppression of the alloactivating capacity. Our results indicate that people protected from sunburn by sunscreens may be exposed to UV for a long period of time, and thereby subject themselves to its immunosuppressive action.