Radiologic, Pathologic and Molecular Attributes of Two Types of Papillary Renal Adenocarcinomas

Objective: Most papillary renal tumors are not as aggressive as clear cell carcinomas and thus carry a better prognosis. However, several reports in the literature have demonstrated a subset of patients with papillary tumors that have a more aggressive biology and advanced stage at presentation. We compared several parameters of these subsets of renal tumors in an effort to characterize these lesions. Patients and methods: We reviewed 391 cases of nephrectomies that were performed for cancer over a 20-year period from four institutions. Of these, 41 were documented as papillary adenocarcinomas. We reviewed these cases with respect to stage at presentation, size, vascularity on (computerized tomography) CT scan, histology, and cytokeratin immunohistology. Results: Thirty-two of the lesions presented in the fifth, sixth, seventh and eighth decades of life (Type I), while most of the remaining 9 tumors (Type II) presented in the fourth decade of life, and in more advanced stages. Tumor volumes ranged from 84 cm3 to 1660 cm3. Type I tumors had an average size of 515 cm3