A quality-control program for colposcopic practice

Quality control is accepted as an integral part of the cytology laboratoryʼs activities. However, provision of similar safeguards for colposcopic practice in assessing patients with abnormal cervical cytology has been an elusive problem. This report describes the quality-control program for colposcopy that is used province-wide in British Columbia for 21 hospital-based clinics staffed by 35 colposcopists. Copies of the results of all colposcopic examinations performed are sent to the Central Cytology Laboratory where the program is coordinated and the data are collated, analyzed, and evaluated. These data are used to set standards against which each colposcopistʼs performance and activity can be measured. One of the quality-control indicators used is a comparison between the colposcopic impression of the lesion and the corresponding direct biopsy diagnosis. Correlation within one histologic degree occurred in 86% of patients examined; this information was used to set a performance standard of 80% as the quality-control index for this particular indicator. Three colposcopists had scores below this standard. Comparisons were also made between presenting cytology, directed biopsy results, initial colposcopic impression, and final colposcopic evaluation (the clinical working diagnosis). The other major aspect of the quality-control program consists of an analysis of all cases of diagnosed invasive cervical cancer in the province in a given year to determine whether any colposcopically related errors occurred in the investigation and management of these cases. This system helps to identify individuals who may benefit from additional training.