A Computational Study of the Cycloaddition of Thiobenzophenone S-Methylide to Thiobenzophenone

The cycloaddition of thiobenzophenone S-methylide to thiobenzophenone, an experimentally well-known reaction, was studied, using (U)HF/3-21G* for finding stationary points and (U)B3LYP/6-31G*//(U)HF/3-21G* single-point calculations for energies. Some optimizations were performed by (U)B3LYP/ 6-31G* to check the reliability of the calculations. The comparison of the concerted pathways and stepwise reactions via C,C-biradicals and C,S-zwitterions showed that the formation of a tetraphenyl-substituted C,C-biradical and its ring closure to 4,4,5,5-tetraphenyl-1,3-dithiolane constitutes the energetically most probable pathway of product formation, despite the fact that the regioisomeric 2,2,4,4-tetraphenyl-substituted product is more favorable by 17 kcal mol-1. Model calculations on bond dissociation energies showed that (U)B3LYP with various basis sets overestimates radical stabilization, whereas CBS-QB3 closely reproduced experimental values. Results with the BLYP functional are similar to those with B3LYP. The consequences of the overestimation of radical stability for the cycloaddition mechanism involving biradicals are discussed. Thiobenzophenone S-methylide, if not captured by a dipolarophile, dimerizes to 2,2,3,3-tetraphenyl-1,4-dithiane. Calculation disclosed likewise a tetraphenyl-substituted C,C-biradical as intermediate.