Kinetics of fluoride release from zinc oxide-based cements

Considerable attention has been given to the release of the cariostatic fluoride ion from glass-based dental cements (dental silicate and glass ionomer). In these, the total available fluoride content is not precisely known since fluorine is distributed between the cross-linked aqueous salt matrix, partially dissolved glass, and undissolved glass. In analogous cements based on zinc oxide the fluoride is added as highly soluble SnF 2. The object of this study is to compare the F − ion release profiles of commercial zinc polycarboxylate and zinc phosphate containing 4.4 and 3.6% SnF 2, respectively. Mixed cements were clamped in split ring moulds to produce discs of 10 mm×1 mm after storage at 37°C for 1 h. Each was weighed and immersed in 10 ml of deionised water. When this changed, at 13 time intervals up to 98 days, the fluoride content was measured using an ion selective electrode. The mean ( N=3) values obtained were expressed cumulatively [F] in μmol F ion/g cement. The total [F] released was 111 for the zinc polycarboxylate and 286 for zinc phosphate compared with total F in the cements of 561 and 464, respectively. When the cumulative [F] was plotted versus t 1/2 close associations were found for both cements. For the polycarboxylate the regression line [F]=10.6 t 1/2+9.9 fitted well over the whole 98 days ( R=0.997). For the phosphate a better fit regression line was obtained using results upto 32 days only; [F]=36.8t 1/2−8.4 (R=0.999). For t>32 days results increasingly deviated from this line. These results fitted a regression line of the form [F]=81.7 log e t−87.3 ( R=0.9997). Comparisons are made with data from previous authors both for zinc phosphate cement and glass-based cements and with diffusion theory of F ion release. It is concluded that zinc-based cements provide some indications of how glass-based cements may behave over long periods of release and that zinc phosphate is the material of clinical choice for orthodontic cementation if maximal fluoride release is the prime criterion.