Ligand density determines the efficiency of negative selection in the thymus

To study the influence of antigen density on the efficiency of negative selection in the thymus, MHC class I (H-2K(b), K(b)) transgenic mice were generated, which expressed a K(b) transgene under the control of its natural promoter at 33% (K(b-lo)) or 150% (K(b-hi)) the surface density of Kb in C57BL/6 (B6, H-2(b)) mice. These mice were crossed to anti-K(b) T-cell receptor (Des-TCR) transgenic mice. In Des-TCRxK(b-hi) double transgenic mice, Des-TCR bearing T cells were completely eliminated during thymocyte maturation. In contrast, in Des-TCRxK(b-lo) double transgenic mice, two populations of Des-TCR T cells were evident, which either expressed the Des-TCR at intermediate density in the absence of CD8 (Des-TCR(int)CD8(-)) or expressed both the Des-TCR and CD8 at low density (Des-TCRloCD8lo). In the thymus of both types of double transgenic mice, no Des-TCR(+)CD4(+)CD8(+) thymocytes were detected, suggesting that deletion of Des-TCR cells occurred before the CD4(+)CD8(+) stage. Because only very few Des-TCR(+) thymocytes were found in Des-TCRxK(b-hi) transgenic mice, deletion of these T cells apparently occurred upon expression of the Des-TCR. By contrast, Des-TCRxK(b-lo) transgenic mice showed distinct populations of Des-TCR(int)CD4-8- and Des-TCR(lo)CD8(lo) thymocytes, suggesting that expression of the CD8 coreceptor was required to allow negative selection to proceed. Functional analyses showed that sublethally irradiated Des-TCRxK(b-lo) double transgenic mice were protected from lethal graft-versus-host disease by injected Des-TCR lymph node cells.