Quality Evaluation of Solid Organ Transplant in Italy for the Period 2000 to 2002 Data from the National Transplant Center

As part of the increased need for transparency and disclosure of information in health care, the Italian Minister of Health has commissioned the Superior Institute of Health to study health outcomes for several procedures, among which is solid organ transplants. We herein report the results of a quality evaluation of solid organ transplants and on the relationship between hospital volume of activity and outcomes, using the data routinely collected by the National Transplant Center during the period 2000 to 2002. We collected and analyzed all the information on solid organ transplants between 2000 and 2002, along with clinical information before and after transplant. Multivariate survival analysis was performed to adjust the follow-up data for the complexity of the cases. Correlation graphs are presented that assess the association between the number of transplants and the adjusted 1-year survival of both the organ and the patient. One-year survival was 92.4% for kidney, 77.8% for liver, and 83.9% for heart. Patient survival was 97.0%, 84.1%, and 83.9%, respectively. A negative correlation was observed between the number of transplants performed by each center and 1-year survival of the organ. Our study indicated that survival after organ transplants in Italy is good and that hospital quality, indirectly measured through survival, overlaps that observed in other Western countries.