Nonsentinel node metastases in breast cancer patients with isolated tumor cells in the sentinel node: implications for completion axillary node dissection

Controversy exists regarding axillary dissection (ALND) for sentinel node (SLN) metastases detected as isolated tumor cells (ITC). We hypothesized that the number of positive non-SLNs is low and ALND is unnecessary for most patients with ITC. From 1995 to 1999, 634 breast cancer patients underwent SLND. SLNs were examined using immunohistochemistry if hematoxylin and eosin was negative. ALND was recommended for ITC-positive SLNs. Seventy-eight patients (12.3%) with ITC-positive SLNs were offered ALND. Sixty-one consented, whereas 17 refused. Fifty-eight (95.1%) had negative non-SLNs. Three (4.9%) had non-SLN metastases. One patient (1.6%) had macrometastatic disease, whereas 2 (3.3%) had micrometastases. No ITC-only–positive SLN patient experienced axillary recurrence. When ALND was performed for ITC, 1.6% of non-SLNs harbored macrometastases and 3.3% had micrometastases. When ALND was not performed, axillary recurrence was not seen. The low risk of non-SLN disease in this study fails to support the routine use of ALND for ITC-positive SLNs.