A preclinical comparison between different opioids: antinociceptive versus adverse effects

Reduced side-effect liability of opioids may enhance the patients quality of life and decrease the incidence of opioid-insensitive pain. Literature offers few comparative data between different opioids at equianalgesic doses. Therefore morphine, fentanyl, buprenorphine, codeine, hydrocodone and oxycodone were compared for analgesic properties and side-effect profiles in rats. Analgesic efficacy was analysed using a tail withdrawal test for acute thermal nociception, a formalin test for chemically induced inflammatory pain and a von Frey test for mechanical hypersensitivity. For side-effect profiling inhibition of gastrointestinal activity was evaluated in a charcoal and ricinus oil test, arterial PCO 2 was determined for measuring respiratory depression, the discriminative stimulus properties linked to the narcotic cue were assessed using a drug discrimination learning test, and motor coordination was tested through rotarod performance. ED 50's for the occurrence of side-effects were compared to ED 50's in behavioural pain tests. Fentanyl had a strong analgesic potency and, compared to other opioids, an acceptable side-effect profiling at analgesic ED 50's. Also consistent was the ceiling effect of buprenorphine implying an increased safety margin for side-effects, but a decreased analgesic efficacy. Differences between opioids as observed in this study can have important indications for their use in acute as well as in the onset of chronic treatments.