Evaluation of Methods for Detecting Substance Use Disorder in Persons With Severe Mental Illness

Substance use disorders are frequently undiagnosed in psychiatric settings. One possible reason for this underdiagnosis is the lack of screening procedures designed or validated specifically for psychiatric patients. To evaluate the utility of current detection methods, (a) criterion diagnoses were established of alcohol use disorder and drug (cannabis or cocaine) use disorder on 320 patients with severe mental illness recently admitted to a psychiatric hospital, using a combination of structured diagnostic interviews and clinician ratings, and (b) the classification accuracy of several substance abuse measures developed for the general population was examined. For this particular sample, demographic variables, clinical variables, medical exams, laboratory tests, and collateral reports did not yield accurate detection. Screens based on self-report were superior to these other approaches but still yielded modest sensitivity. The results suggest that many individuals are classified incorrectly with current techniques.