Experimental study of chemical treatment of coal fly ash to reduce the mobility of priority trace elements

Coal fired electric power plants produce large volumes of fly ash and other coal combustion by-products (CCBs) every year. Although almost 50% of the fly ash produced in the US is recycled for beneficial use, most of the ash material is disposed in dry landfills and ash lagoon impoundments. Fly ash may contain hazardous leachable trace elements such as As, B, Cr, Mo, Ni, Se, Sr and V which have a negative impact on the environment due to potential leaching by acid rain and groundwater with time. Many of the older CCB disposal facilities are unlined and unmonitored and as a result the EPA is currently developing national standards for monitoring CCB disposal sites. The cost to the US electric power industry could exceed one billion dollars if existing and closed CCB disposal facilities come under regulation. Thus simple, low-cost and effective in situ chemical treatment techniques are needed to stabilize hazardous leachable trace elements in the coal combustion by-product (CCB) materials. This paper reports the results of experiments designed to chemically treat fly ash with ferrous sulfate solutions to immobilize hazardous leachable trace elements after disposal. The current study is focused on three acidic and one alkaline fly ash samples collected from electric power plants located in the southeastern United States that were treated with two ferrous sulfate treatment solutions. The first treatment solution contained ferrous sulfate (FS) to give 322 mg/L of dissolved iron, while the second treatment solution contained the same concentration of ferrous sulfate along with excess calcium carbonate (FS + CC) to buffer the pH. Fly ash treatment experiments were carried out at solid:liquid (S:L) ratios of 1:3 and 1:30. The effectiveness of the treatment methods was evaluated by sequentially leaching the treated and the untreated fly ash samples using a synthetic acid rain (SAR) solution (US EPA Method 1312B SPLP fluid) as the leachate. The best overall treatment result was shown by the unbuffered ferrous sulfate solution at the 1:30 S:L ratio, which substantially reduced the mobility of the oxyanion trace elements. The overall mobility reduction achieved for As was 23–72%, B mobility was reduced by 43–80%, Cr by 45–77%, Mo by 21–90%, Se by 41–85% and V by 41–53% The unbuffered ferrous sulfate treatment was not effective for immobilization of the cationic trace elements Ni and Sr.