Prophage maintenance is determined by environment-dependent selective sweeps rather than mutational availability

Prophages, viral sequences integrated into bacterial genomes, can be beneficial and costly. Despite the risk of prophage activation and subsequent bacterial death, active prophages are present in most bacterial genomes. However, our understanding of the selective forces that maintain prophages in bacterial populations is limited. Combining experimental evolution with stochastic modeling, we show that prophage maintenance and loss are primarily determined by environmental conditions that alter the net fitness effect of a prophage on its bacterial host. When prophages are too costly, they are rapidly lost through environment-specific sequences of selective sweeps. Conflicting selection pressures that select against the prophage but for a prophage-encoded accessory gene can maintain prophages. The dynamics of prophage maintenance additionally depend on the sociality of this accessory gene. Prophage-encoded genes that exclusively benefit the lysogen maintain prophages at higher frequencies compared with genes that benefit the entire population. That is because the latter can protect phage-free “cheaters,” reducing the benefit of maintaining the prophage. Our simulations suggest that environmental variation plays a larger role than mutation rates in determining prophage maintenance. These findings highlight the complexity of selection pressures that act on mobile genetic elements and challenge our understanding of the role of environmental factors relative to random chance events in shaping the evolutionary trajectory of bacterial populations. By shedding light on the key factors that shape microbial populations in the face of environmental changes, our study significantly advances our understanding of the complex dynamics of microbial evolution and diversification. •Escherichia coli lambda lysogens lose costly phages•The cost of phages depends on prophage benefits and the environment•The carriage of prophages is prolonged by carrying beneficial genes Bailey et al. show that bacterial lysogens maintain or lose prophages depending on the confluence of prophage and lysogen genotypes with environmental factors. During ampicillin and mitomycin C exposure, lysogens lose prophages based on the type of benefit the prophage provides. Modeling shows that benefit type affects prophage maintenance.