Alternative uses for urban autumn tree leaves: A case study in profitability and greenhouse gas emissions for the city of Berlin

Autumn tree leaves collect as waste on many city streets every year. In the city of Berlin, they are usually collected and transported for composting as their final treatment, which emits greenhouse gases (GHG) into the atmosphere. This study assesses alternative end uses of autumn tree leaves in order explore the potential of reducing GHG emissions while producing electric energy from residual biomass. It uses a combination of partial life-cycle assessments and net present value (NPV) to explore the different net GHG emissions and economic benefits of using autumn tree leaves for the following scenarios: anaerobic digestion (biogas), gasification, and co-firing. Assuming the use of 36,000 tonnes of leaves per year, co-firing in existing power plants shows the highest NPV, of between 10.3 million and 12.1 million euros for a 10-year lifetime, in line with the phase-out of coal combustion in Germany. It also results in the lowest net GHG emissions, with savings of between 252,000 and 144,000 tonnes of CO2eq. Gasification in new plants resulted in similar NPVs, estimated at between 9.80 and 9.86 million euros over a 20-year investment horizon, but lower emissions savings of 178,000 to 127,000 tonnes of CO2eq. Biogas production showed high emissions savings of 204,000 to 203,000 tonnes of CO2eq, but a much lower NPV of between 2.3 and 2.5 million euros. Composting was the only scenario with positive net GHG emissions. The amount of energy retrieved from the conversion technologies and the electrical tariff applied were the main drivers of these results. Other aspects that can shape the results include the availability of infrastructure and transport distances. The results are highly sensitive in both cases to the dryness of the leaves, while electricity tariffs influenced the economic performance considerably.