Differences in the Reaction Mechanisms of Chlorine Atom and Hydroxyl Radical with Organic Compounds: From Thermodynamics to Kinetics

Hydroxyl radical (HO•) and chlorine atom (Cl•) are common reactive species in aqueous environments. However, the intrinsic difference in their reactions with organic compounds has not been revealed. This study compared the reaction mechanisms of HO• and Cl• with 13 aromatic and 11 aliphatic compounds by quantum chemical calculation and laser flash photolysis. Both HO• and Cl• can spontaneously react with aromatic compounds via radical adduct formation (RAF), hydrogen atom transfer (HAT), and single electron transfer (SET) pathways. The SET reactions of Cl• were more thermodynamically favorable than HO•, but contrary results were obtained for HAT reactions. According to the free energy of activation (ΔG aq ‡), the dominant oxidation mechanisms of aromatic compounds were RAF and SET by HO• and SET by Cl•. The important role of SET in the HO• reactions with aromatic compounds was further verified by accurately calculating the solvation free energy of HO•/HO– and experimentally tracking the radical cations, which were generally neglected in previous studies. Meanwhile, the ΔG aq ‡ value of each reaction pathway of Cl• was lower than that of HO•, resulting in higher rate constants of Cl• with aromatic compounds than HO•. For saturated aliphatic compounds, HAT was found to be the only mechanism accounting for their transformation by HO• and Cl•. This study proposed general rules for the reaction mechanisms of HO• and Cl• and unraveled their differences in the aspects of thermodynamics and kinetics, providing fundamental information for understanding contaminant transformation in processes involving HO• and Cl•.