Recycled waste substrates: A systematic review

The growing interest in utilizing recycled waste substrates (RWS) in ecosystem services and environmental remediation aligns with the “waste to wealth” concept and the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Despite the promising potential of RWS, research gaps remain due to a lack of comprehensive reviews on their production and applications. This systematic review attempts to synthesize and critically assess the scientific footprint of RWS through robust methodology and thorough investigation. Characterization of scientific literature, network analysis, and systematic review were conducted on articles indexed in the Web of Science and Scopus databases. Quantitative and qualitative analyses were performed on 140 articles selected by the rigorous article screening process executed using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) protocol. The findings map the scientific literature and research themes in RWS. Around 66 % of studies in RWS used a multiple research approach, primarily experiments with case studies. Key research topics identified include (A) Technical domains - types of wastes and recycling techniques in RWS production and parameters influencing the substrate quality; (B) Application domains: environmental remediation of soil and agriculture and horticulture. The use of RWS in urban green infrastructure, particularly for green roofs and vegetative walls, and the potential for LCA studies on RWS production and applications emerge as promising areas for future research. This systematic review also presents a conceptual framework model (CFM) on RWS research, encapsulating the state-of-the-art themes, risks, limitations and constraints, and future research avenues. [Display omitted] •Interest in RWS aligns with SDGs and “waste to wealth” concept•Research gaps persist regarding the understanding and perceptions of RWS•This systematic review critically synthesizes the scientific footprints of RWS•Mapping of scientific literature, thematic analysis, and critical appraisal were done•CFM provides comprehensive understanding of scientific research frontiers in RWS