Lower continental crust formation through focused flow in km-scale melt conduits: The zoned ultramafic bodies of the Chilas Complex in the Kohistan island arc (NW Pakistan)

Whole-rock and Sm–Nd isotopic data of the main units of the Chilas zoned ultramafic bodies (Kohistan paleo-island arc, NW Pakistan) indicate that ultramafic rocks and gabbronorite sequences stem from a common magma. However, field observations rule out formation of both ultramafic and mafic sequences in terms of gravitational crystal settling in a large magma chamber. Contacts between ultramafic and gabbronorite sequences show emplacement of the dunitic bodies into a semi-consolidated gabbronoritic crystal-mush, which in turn has intruded and reacted with the ultramafic rocks to produce concentric zoning. Field and petrological observations indicate a replacive origin of the dunite. Bulk Mg#'s of dunitic rocks range from 0.87–0.81 indicating that the dunite-forming melt underwent substantial fractionation–differentiation and that percolative fractional crystallization probably generated the dunitic core. The REE chemistry of clinopyroxene in primitive dunite samples and the Nd isotopic composition of ultramafic rocks are in equilibrium with the surrounding gabbronorite. Accordingly, liquids that formed the dunitic rocks and later the mafic sequence derived from a similar depleted source ( ε Nd∼4.8). We propose a mechanism for the comagmatic emplacement, where km-scale ultramafic bodies represent continuous channels reaching down into the upper mantle. The melt-filled porosity in these melt channels diminishes the mean-depth-integrated density difference to the surrounding rocks. Due to buoyancy forces, melt channels raise into the overlying crustal sequence. In the light of such processes, the ultramafic bodies are interpreted as melt channels through which the Chilas gabbronorite sequence was fed. The estimated basaltic–andesitic, low Mg# (∼0.53) bulk composition of the Chilas gabbronorite sequence closely matches estimates of lower crustal compositions. Since the mafic sequence originated from a primary, high Mg# (> 0.7) basaltic arc magma, differentiation of such high Mg# magmas within km-scale isolated melt conduits may explain the “Mg#-gap” between bulk estimates of the continental crust and primary basaltic magmas, a major paradox in the andesite model of crust formation.