Conflicting selection pressures on seed size and germination caused by carnivorous seed dispersers

Plants produce nutritious, fleshy fruits that attract various animals to facilitate seed dispersal and recruitment dynamic. Species‐specific differential selection of seed size by multiple frugivorous disperser assemblages may affect the subsequent germination of the ingested seeds. However, there is little empirical evidence supporting this association. In the present study, we documented conflicting selection pressures exerted on seed size and germination by five frugivorous carnivores on a mammal‐dispersed pioneer tree, the date‐plum persimmon (Diospyros lotus), in a subtropical forest. Fecal analyses revealed that these carnivores acted as primary seed dispersers of D. lotus. We also observed that seed sizes were selected based on body mass and were species‐specific, confirming the “gape limitation” hypothesis; three small carnivores (the masked palm civet Paguma larvata, yellow‐throated marten Martes flavigula, and Chinese ferret‐badger Melogale moschata) significantly preferred to disperse smaller seeds in comparison with control seeds obtained directly from wild plants whereas the largest Asiatic black bears (Ursus thibetanus) ingested larger seeds. Seeds dispersed by medium‐sized hog badgers (Arctonyx albogularis) were not significantly different from control seeds. However, regarding the influence of gut passage on seed germination, three arboreal dispersal agents (martens, civets, and bears) enhanced germination success whereas terrestrial species (ferret‐badgers and hog badgers) inhibited the germination process compared with undigested control seeds. These conflicting selection pressures on seed size and germination may enhance the heterogeneity of germination dynamics and thus increase species fitness through diversification of the regeneration niche. Our results advance our understanding of seed dispersal mechanisms and have important implications for forest recruitment and ecosystem dynamics. We found the conflicting selection pressures exerted on seed size and germination by five frugivorous carnivores for a mammal‐dispersed pioneer tree, the data plum persimmon (Diospyros lotus). Selections of these five carnivore on seed size was based on body mass, but theses favoring selections did not run to their effects on germination which is mainly linked to life history (i.e. arboreal and terrestrial). The conflicting selection pressures may enhance the heterogeneity of germination dynamics and thus increase species fitness through diversification