Recurrent peripheral odontogenic keratocyst: Review of the literature and presentation of a novel case initially masquerading as an atypical infected lateral periodontal cyst

To review published cases and case series of the peripheral odontogenic keratocyst (POKC) of the gingiva, report an unusual presentation, and discuss lesional recurrence. A search of the English language literature for gingival OKCs was conducted. The inclusion of new case yielded a database containing 29 affected patients. Clinical, surgical, radiographic, and histopathologic findings have been summarized. With available patient demographics, 62.5% were female and 37.5% were male, with an overall mean age at diagnosis of 53.8 years. There was near-equal lesional affinity for the jaws, of which 44.0% occurred in the posterior region, 32.0% anteriorly, and 24.0% overlapped these areas. Twenty-five percent of lesions had a normal color, 30.0% appeared yellow, 20.0% were white, and 10.0% were blue. The majority of lesions were < 1 cm and nearly 42% manifested exudation or fluctuance. Lesional pain was infrequent. Pressure resorption was recorded in 45.8% of cases. Most lesions were managed with conservative surgical modalities. Follow-up information was available in 16 primary cases, of which 5 recurred, signifying a 31.3% recurrence rate, including the featured case, which recurred twice. To reduce recurrence of a gingival OKC, supraperiosteal dissection is advocated. Further, it is advised to follow POKCs for 5–7 years postoperatively, remaining vigilant for subtle clinical manifestations of recurrence. Timely discovery and excision of a POKC of the gingiva may decrease the incidence of a mucogingival defect.