Neural and self-report indices of cognitive reappraisal moderate the association between sensitivity to uncertain threat and problem alcohol use

Exaggerated reactivity to threats that are uncertain (U-threat) is a risk factor for problem alcohol use. Data suggest that exaggerated reactivity to U-threat is associated with chronic anxiety and motivation for coping-oriented drinking. Not all individuals with high U-threat reactivity engage in excessive drinking and theory and research suggest that individual differences in emotion regulation, particularly frequency and effectiveness of cognitive reappraisal, are potential moderators of this well-established link. The aim of the current study was to test this hypothesis using a multimodal laboratory design. A total of 83 volunteers with depression and/or anxiety completed a well-validated threat sensitivity task and two complimentary assessments of cognitive reappraisal. Threat sensitivity was measured using startle eyeblink potentiation during threat-of-electric shock. Cognitive reappraisal was measured using self-report and estimates of prefrontal cortex activation (PFC; i.e., ventrolateral, dorsolateral and dorsomedial) during instructed reappraisal during functional magnetic resonance imaging. Results revealed self-reported and PFC indices of reappraisal were correlated within-subjects. Additionally, self-reported and ventrolateral (vlPFC) activation during reappraisal moderated the association between reactivity to U-threat and problem alcohol use. Across both measures, at low engagement in reappraisal, greater startle reactivity to U-threat was associated with greater problem alcohol use. At high engagement in reappraisal, there was no association between U-threat reactivity and problem alcohol use. Together, the findings reveal that exaggerated reactivity to U-threat may be a particularly robust risk factor for problem alcohol use in the context of impaired or ineffective emotion regulation. •Increased reactivity to uncertain threat (U-threat) is associated with alcohol abuse.•Results show individual differences in cognitive reappraisal moderate this link.•U-threat relates to alcohol abuse at low levels of cognitive reappraisal only.•Findings are consistent across self-reported and neural markers of reappraisal.