Responsiveness of Subcutaneous Fat, Intermuscular Fat, and Muscle Anatomical Cross-Sectional Area of the Thigh to Longitudinal Body Weight Loss and Gain: Data from the Osteoarthritis Initiative (OAI)

Abstract Thigh subcutaneous (SCF) and intermuscular (IMF) fat have been associated with joint health and function. Here, we explore the (sex-specific) responsiveness of SCF, IMF, and muscle during longitudinal weight loss and gain, as well as the change in questionnaire-based and physical performance-based knee function measures. This exploratory study included 103 Osteoarthritis Initiative (OAI) participants, who displayed a ≥10% weight loss or gain between baseline (BL) and 2-year (Y2) follow-up (and maintained half of that weight loss until year 4) and had axial 3T magnetic resonance images (MRI) for measuring SCF, IMF, and muscle cross sectional areas (CSAs). The standardized response mean (SRM = mean divided by the standard deviation of the change) was used as a measure of responsiveness. A total of 52 OAI participants (73% women) displayed ≥10% weight loss, and 51 (67% women) ≥10% weight gain. Both SCF and IMF CSAs showed a significant decrease (mean change) with weight loss (SCF: −22%, SRM = −1.2; IMF: −15%, SRM = −0.7) and a significant increase with weight gain (SCF: +27%, SRM = 1.1; IMF: +21%, SRM = 0.6). Muscle CSAs showed significant changes during weight loss (extensor: −8.3%, SRM = −1.1; flexor: −7.2%, SRM = −1.0), but not during weight gain. Knee function measures were not relevantly associated with bidirectional changes in body weight. SCF and IMF CSAs are highly responsive to bidirectional weight change, whereas muscle CSAs were only responsive to weight loss. These findings highlight that MRI represents a sensitive tool for monitoring changes in thigh adipose tissue composition that may be applied during specific diet and/or exercise interventions.