Fishing in a Puddle of Doubt and Disbelief?: A Rejoinder to the Speed et al. Commentary

In the article “Religiously/Spiritually Involved, but in Doubt or Disbelief—Why? Healthy?”, Mrdjenovich (in J Relig Health https://doi.org/10.1007/s10943-018-0711-2 , 2018 ) explored the practices of religious attendance and prayer among atheists and agnostic theists. Speed et al. (in J Relig Health https://doi.org/10.1007/s10943-020-01109-1 , 2020 ) offered a commentary regarding Mrdjenovich’s (2018) article with attention to moderators of associations between religious/spiritual constructs and health outcomes. In this rejoinder, I review Speed et al.’s (2020) commentary and I identify a number of concerns, both with their observations and ostensive oversights involving qualitative research methodology, the utility of survey data, the domain of belief, and the impact of calls for a pluralistic approach in the religion-heath research field. I conclude that Mrdjenovich does not misunderstand mechanisms of the (non)religion-health relationship as much as Speed et al. seem to misinterpret Mrdjenovich’s (2018) purpose, perspective, and default position on the issues. I reiterate that a concerted effort is required to study health outcomes among religious minorities.