Reflection-in-action during high-fidelity simulation: A concept analysis

Our primary aim was to complete an in-depth analysis of the concept of “reflection-in-action” during high-fidelity simulation. We sought to identify what is currently known about the topic and establish a strong foundation for theory development regarding cultivating reflection-in-action during high-fidelity simulation. Walker and Avant's (2011) systematic approach to concept analysis was used as a framework to develop a comprehensive understanding of reflection-in-action during high-fidelity simulation. We conducted a review of literature on reflection-in-action (with open date parameters) in PubMed, Eric, PsychInfo, ABI/Business Premium Collection, and the Cumulative Index of Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL) electronic data bases using key terms “reflection-in-action” AND “simulation”. In addition, we hand-searched reference lists from key articles in the journals Simulation in Healthcare, Simulation and Gaming, and Advances in Simulation. Our search resulted in 22 articles, from 1998 to 2019, that met the inclusion criteria. Four defining attributes of the concept were identified: (1) reflection-in-action must occur during high-fidelity simulation and cannot be captured within post-simulation debriefing; (2) a critical learning juncture must occur and be identified by the learners; (3) a pause in student action must occur during the high-fidelity simulation; and (4) knowledge sharing must occur through out-loud discussion. Antecedents, consequences, and empirical referents of reflection-in-action were also identified. The insights from this review may enhance the ability of nursing educators to effectively support reflection-in-action within high-fidelity simulation nursing education. This concept analysis also establishes a foundation for reflection-in-action strategy development, as well as suggestions for future research in high-fidelity simulation nursing education.