Application and evaluation of fracture mechanics failure concepts to precracked vessels

The elastic-plastic fracture mechanics concepts R-curve method, Two Criteria Approach, COD concept and Battelle formula were applied on three tested vessels made of low and high tough and fine grained structural steel and X 8 Ni 9 with an axial notch on the outer surface. Apart from the R-curve method for the vessel made of low tough material, failure loads were conservatively calculated. The COD concept could not be applied to these vessels and failure geometries using the well known design curve. A modification of the COD concept by means of FE-calculations was made so that a correlation between the displacement at the crack tip and at the vessel surface could be determined. With this procedure, the calculated load at fracture was only 8% below the experimental result.