Corroborative evidence for an association between initial hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenocortical axis reactivity and subsequent habituation in humans

•Initial HPA axis reactivity was strongly associated with subsequent habituation.•Unbiased statistical analyses supported the HPA reactivity-habituation association.•Health implications of HPA reactivity and habituation should be considered jointly. The extant literature predicts that initial hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenocortical (HPA) axis response magnitude and subsequent habituation are associated with health, such that both heightened stress reactivity and non-habituation to repeated stressors are associated with disease. Yet, despite evidence for an association between initial HPA axis reactivity and subsequent habituation, the extant literature often considers health implications of these stress response patterns independently or make interpretations based on an initial response alone. This may be because past tests of the association between reactivity and habituation were subject to statistical bias (e.g., regression to the mean), and no prior work has examined the association between initial cortisol reactivity and subsequent habituation using analytic strategies capable of estimating the unbiased relationship between initial value (i.e., reactivity) and subsequent change (i.e., habituation). Accordingly, the present investigation drew from two previously published studies to test the association between initial HPA axis reactivity and subsequent habituation using analytic strategies capable of estimating the relationship between initial reactivity and subsequent habituation with minimal bias. We examined salivary cortisol and plasma ACTH responses to three repeated social-evaluative stressors (Study 1) and salivary cortisol responses to two repeated social-evaluative stressors (Study 2). As predicted, results indicated a negative relationship (Pearson’s r ranging from -0.27 to -0.91) where initial HPA axis reactivity was associated with subsequent habituation across both studies, even when using estimation procedures capable of producing an unbiased estimate of this relationship. Results support the claim that initial HPA axis reactivity to acute stress is associated with subsequent habituation, such that initially high reactors are likely to habituate, whereas initially blunted reactors are likely to sensitize. In view of these results, hypothesized long-term health implications of acute cortisol reactivity and habituation patterns should be considered in tandem.