Cobalt(II) “Scorpionate” complexes as electronic ground state models for cobalt-substituted zinc enzymes: Structure investigation by magnetic circular dichroism

Zinc centers in pseudo-tetrahedral geometry are widely found in biology, often with three histidine ligands from protein. The trispyrazolylborate “scorpionate” ligand is used as a model for this tris(histidine) motif, and spectroscopically active CoII is often used as a substitute for spectroscopically silent ZnII. In this work, four pseudo-tetrahedral scorpionate complexes with the formula (Tpt-Bu,Tn)CoL, where Tpt-Bu,Tn = hydrotris(3-tert-butyl, 5–2′-thienyl-pyrazol-1-yl)borate anion and L = Cl−, N3−, NCO−, or NCS−, were studied using variable-temperature, variable-field magnetic circular dichroism (VTVH MCD) spectroscopy. The major goal was to determine the axial and rhombic zero field splitting (ZFS) parameters (D and E, respectively) of these S = 3/2 systems and compare these ZFS parameters to those determined previously by high-frequency and -field electron paramagnetic resonance (HFEPR) spectroscopy on the same (L = Cl− and NCS−) or closely related complexes. Additionally, HFEPR studies were undertaken here on the complexes with L = N3−, NCO−. Crystal structures for these two complexes are also first reported here. The values of D determined by VTVH MCD were + 12.8 and + 3.6 cm−1 for the L = Cl− and NCS- complexes, respectively. These values are in close agreement with those for the same complexes as previously determined by HFEPR. The values of D determined by VTVH MCD were + 3.0 and + 6.6 cm−1 for the L = N3− and NCO- complexes, respectively. These values were not as close to those determined by HFEPR in the present study, which are 4.2 cm−1 ≤ |D| ≤ 5.6 cm−1 in Tpt-Bu,TnCoN3, and 8.3 cm−1 ≤ |D| ≤ 11.0 cm−1 in Tpt-Bu,TnCoNCO. The bands in MCD spectra of these complexes were assigned in C3v symmetry and a complete ligand-field analysis of the MCD data was made using the Angular Overlap Model (AOM), which is compared to previous results. Magnetic circular dichroism was used to determine the zero field splitting parameter, D, in complexes of formula (Tpt-Bu,Tn)CoL, (Tpt-Bu,Tn = hydrotris(3-tert-butyl, 5–2′-thienyl-pyrazol-1-yl)borate anion; L = Cl−, N3−, NCO−, or NCS−). The values of D are in agreement with those determined by high-frequency and -field electron paramagnetic resonance. [Display omitted] •Magnetic circular dichroism (MCD) can determine zero-field splitting (ZFS) in CoII.•High-frequency and -field EPR (HFEPR) values of ZFS in CoII are more precise.•MCD values of ZFS in CoII are still comparable to those determined by HFEPR.•MCD is more s