Aging effects on the mobility of Pb in soil: Influence on the energy requirements in electroremediation

This paper studies the possible differences in the behavior of lead as a contaminant in soil samples when it is present as “naturally-aged” for decades after the contamination, and when it has been spiked in the laboratory. This behavior differences are stablished mainly in two ways: as changes in the fractionation analysis obtained after a sequential extraction procedure (SEP) and as changes in the efficiency of the acid-enhanced electroremediation (EKR) technique. Additionally, aging effects have been studied for almost five years. In the case of the lead-spiked soil the influence of storage conditions on contaminant behavior have also been explored: 1) samples stored in capped containers at constant moisture conditions, and 2) samples in containers open to the atmosphere, with periods of water flooding and drying. Lab-spiked and the “naturally-aged” contaminants show very different behavior with respect not only to SEP analysis but also to EKR experiments. The soil spiked with a soluble lead salt presents a higher percent in the more mobile fractions. Regarding storage conditions, some changes were observed in the lead distribution along the vertical soil profile for samples stored in uncapped containers. The EKR results were also in agreement with those from fractionation analysis. Energy requirements for the remediation were estimated by a mathematical model with important differences obtained for the different soil samples. Results are indicating that it will be very unreliable to draw estimations for the “naturally-aged” soils from contaminant-spiked samples. [Display omitted] •Aging of spiked soil is compared with real contaminated soil.•No aging effects on Pb mobility in spiked soil has been observed after 5 years.•The behavior of Pb from spiked and real soils under electric field is analyzed.•Soil mineralogy and other environmental factors should be considered in EKR studies.