Death without sex--the 'problem of the small' and selection for reproductive economy in flowering plants

Most of the resident plants within vegetation fail to leave descendants because of death without sex--i.e. sexual reproduction fails (zero fecundity), primarily because of relatively small plant size. I propose that this 'problem of the small' represents one of the principal driving forces of evolution by natural selection, and that the main product of this selection is 'reproductive economy', manifested by several plant traits that are widely distributed among angiosperms: sexual maturity at a relatively young age and small size, relatively small seed size, selfing (including through mixed mating), and of particular interest here, clonality. In non-clonal species, an offspring develops from a zygote into a single 'rooted unit', i.e. a distinct vascular transition point between live shoot and root tissue. Clonal species can produce an indeterminate number of these rooted unit offspring asexually, all as products of a single zygote. Clonality is a common strategy in angiosperms because it confers a potential two-fold fitness benefit--especially in relatively small species--by promoting longevity of the zygote product, while at the same time providing a fecundity supplement (through asexual multiplication of rooted units), thereby allowing offspring production economically, i.e. without requiring large adult size, and without even requiring the fertilization of ovules. The primary fitness benefit from clonality, therefore, is that the somatic product of a zygote can effectively avoid an intrinsic limitation predicted for all non-clonal plants: the trade-off between longevity and the potential rate of offspring/descendant production. These major fitness benefits of clonality are explored in considering why clonality is less common in larger species, why the largest species (trees) generally do not have the longest-lived zygote product, and in re-assessing traditional and recent views concerning the loss of sex in clonal plants, the predicted trade-off between the size and number of clonal offspring, and the predicted trade-off between sexual and asexual reproduction.