Marine super(14)C reservoir ages for 19th century whales and molluscs from the North Atlantic

In order to compare radiocarbon dates on marine and terrestrial samples the former have to be corrected for a reservoir age. We present reservoir ages from dating 21 whales collected 1860-1901 and recalculating dates of 23 molluscs collected 1857-1926. Most of the whales were caught along the coast of Norway, but one is from France and one from Iceland. We assume the former mainly lived in the North and equatorial Atlantic and in the Norwegian Sea. Whales feed only on pelagic organisms and will provide the reservoir age for the open ocean surface water. However, they travel long distances and will integrate the reservoir ages of the different water masses along their way. Molluscs (dated from Norway, Spitsbergen and Arctic Canada) are stationary and monitor the sea water passing their dwelling site, but some also take up carbon from particulate food or sediment pore water. Coastal water also often contains some continental carbon. We present two different views on how to analyze and interpret the data. Mangerud recommends to use reservoir ages based on a combination of the whale and mollusc dates, i.e. 380+/-30 and 360+/-30 yr relative to Intcal04 and British oak, respectively, and a Delta R value of 20+/-30 for the surface water in the N-Atlantic and Norwegian Sea. Bondevik and Gulliksen maintain that the reservoir age - and Delta R - along the Norwegian coast is latitude dependant, with Delta R-values increasing from -3+/-22 in the South to 105+/-24 at Spitsbergen. Whales, reflecting North Atlantic open ocean surface water have lower Delta R (7+/-11) than most molluscs.