Is surgical resection and observation sufficient for stage I and II sacrococcygeal germ cell tumors? A case series and review

Background Sacrococcygeal teratoma (SCT) is the most common germ cell tumor (GCT) of infancy. Up to 35% of infants may have malignant elements. The standard of care for SCT with malignant elements (SCT‐ME) has been surgery and chemotherapy. However, cases where low‐stage SCT‐ME have been successfully observed following resection have been reported. Procedure To better understand the outcomes of low‐stage SCT‐ME that do not receive chemotherapy, we reviewed SCT pathology reports from five children's hospitals from 1999 to 2009. Information regarding staging workup, tumor markers, treatment, and outcome was collected for patients with stage I or II SCT‐ME. An English language literature review was also performed. Results Seventy‐four SCT were identified: 51 stage I and 23 stage II; 13 (18%) were SCT‐ME: 5 stage I and 8 stage II; four stage I and four stage II tumors were not treated with chemotherapy. No stage I tumors recurred; all of the stage II tumors recurred and were successfully salvaged, two had no ME at recurrence. We identified another 10 stage I SCT‐ME in the literature managed with active surveillance—two recurred and were successfully treated with surgery and chemotherapy. Conclusions Overall, of the 14 cases of stage I SCT‐ME, 12 survived with no recurrence and the two who did recur were successfully treated with platinum‐based chemotherapy (EFS = 86%, overall survival [OS] = 100%); this suggests that patients with stage I SCT‐ME could be observed after surgery and treated only upon recurrence. Stage II SCT‐ME require further study in a clinical trial setting.