Video-EEG results and clinical characteristics in patients with psychogenic nonepileptic spells: The effect of a coexistent epilepsy

Abstract Rationale Epilepsy and psychogenic nonepileptic spells (PNES) can coexist, often posing diagnostic and therapeutic challenges. We sought to identify clinical and historical characteristics of two groups of patients, those with coexisting epilepsy and PNES and those with PNES alone, and determine the prevalence of coexisting epilepsy/PNES with strict diagnostic criteria in a large group of epilepsy monitoring unit (EMU) patients. Methods We reviewed the medical records of all consecutive patients admitted to the Vanderbilt University Medical Center Adult EMU between July 1, 2007 and June 30, 2012. We identified patients with recorded PNES and classified them as having coexisting epilepsy/PNES or PNES alone and then systematically compared the clinical characteristics of these two groups. Results A total of 1567 patient medical records were reviewed. The prevalence rate of coexisting epilepsy/PNES was 5.2% among all EMU admissions (12.3% of all patients with epilepsy and 14.8% of all patients with PNES). These rates were lower when patients with interictal epileptiform activity (IEA) alone and no recorded ictal discharges were not included in the group with epilepsy (2.6%, 6.2%, and 7.4%, respectively). The accuracy of pre-EMU clinical suspicion was significantly higher in the group with PNES-only. Patients with epilepsy/PNES were significantly more likely to require more than one EMU admission for definitive diagnosis. The first PNES event preceded an epileptic seizure (ES) in 94.4% of patients with epilepsy/PNES. The group with PNES-only had significantly higher suggestibility, and the group with epilepsy/PNES had a significantly higher presence of epilepsy risk factors. Abnormal neurological examination and abnormal brain MRI were also significantly more common in the group with epilepsy/PNES. Conclusions Our study defined the prevalence of coexisting epilepsy/PNES in a large cohort with strict diagnostic criteria and outlined specific clinical and historical characteristics differentiating the two groups of patients with coexisting epilepsy/PNES and PNES-only. These findings should help guide clinicians to reach the correct diagnosis faster and provide appropriate treatment earlier.