Targets for Radiation-Induced Cell Death: When DNA Damage Doesn't Kill

Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) K1 and radiosensitive CHO irs-20 cells were synchronized in S phase and labeled for 10 min with 5-125I-iodo-2-deoxyuridine (125IdU). The cells were washed, incubated in fresh medium for 1 h for incorporation of the intracellular radionucleotides into DNA, and then frozen (80C) for accumulation of 125I decays. At intervals after freezing, when the cells had accumulated the desired number of decays, aliquots of the frozen cells were thawed and plated to determine survival. The survival curves for K1 and irs-20 cells were similar from 100 to 30 survival. At higher 125I doses (more decays/cell), the survival of K1 cells continued to decline exponentially, but the survival of X-ray-sensitive irs- 20 cells remained at approximately 30 even after the cells had accumulated 1265 decays/cell. The results contradict the notion that increased DNA damage inevitably causes increased cell death. To account for these findings, we propose a model that postulates the existence of a second radiation target. According to this model, radiation damage to DNA may be necessary to induce cell death, but DNA damage alone is not sufficient to kill cells. We infer from the survival response of irs-20 cells that damage to a second (non-DNA) structure is involved in cell death, and that this structure directly affects the repair of DNA and cell survival.