Structural isomerism in tris-tolyl halo-phosphonium and halo-arsonium tri-halides, [(CH3C6H4)3EX][X3], (E = P, As; X = Br, I)

The group 15 ligands (o-CH(3)C(6)H(4))(3)P, (m-CH(3)C(6)H(4))(3)P, (p-CH(3)C(6)H(4))(3)P, Ph(3)As, (o-CH(3)C(6)H(4))(3)As and (p-CH(3)C(6)H(4))(3)As have been reacted with two equivalents of di-iodine or di-bromine to yield complexes of formula R(3)EX(4) (E = P, As; X = I, Br). These halogenated group 15 compounds are ionic, [R(3)EX][X(3)] consisting of halo-phosphonium or halo-arsonium cations and trihalide anions. These adducts exhibit structural isomerism and may exist either as simple 1:1 ion pairs, [R(3)EX][X(3)], isomer (A), which display a weak XX interaction between cation and anion, or as a 2:1 complex, which consists of a [{R(3)EX}(2)X(3)](+) cationic species made up of two [R(3)EX](+) cations interacting with one [X(3)](-) anion. The overall charge is balanced by a second [X(3)](-) anion. These 2:1 species also exhibit structural isomerism due to subtle differences in the connectivity of the [{R(3)EX}(2)X(3)](+) fragment, as the {R(3)EX}(+) units may either interact at the same end of the [X(3)](-) ion, to give a Y-shaped motif, isomer (B), or at opposite ends, giving a Z-shaped motif, isomer (C). The type of structural isomer formed is related to the way in which [Ar(3)EX](+) cations pack together via aryl embraces. Isomer (A) and (C) structures form chains of side-to-side, anti-parallel embracing cations. In (A) and (C) structures a square-like stacking motif of cations is observed. In contrast, isomer (B) structures feature side-to-side, parallel embracing cations, and do not exhibit the square motif.