Comparison of establishment methods for extensive green roofs in southern Sweden

The most common technique for establishment of thin extensive green roofs in Sweden has been using prefabricated vegetation mats. Our study investigated (1) how the establishment of green roofs in Sweden was influenced by the establishment method (prefabricated vegetation mat, plug-plant, shoot), substrate composition and species mixture, and (2) whether on-site construction was a possible alternative. The establishment of the vegetation, which in all cases consisted of succulent species, was recorded using the quadrate point intercept method in fixed plots and the success measured as frequency cover. Prefabricated vegetation mats had higher succulent plant cover than on-site constructed roofs. There was no difference in succulent plant cover between plots established using plug-plants compared to shoots. Shoot-established plots had more moss than the other establishment methods. The commercial substrate ‘Roof soil’ had significantly higher succulent plant cover than the other substrates, which might be related to a higher nutrient content. The organic content of the non-commercial substrates was rapidly decomposed. The standard species mixture produced a higher cover than both the mix developed for northern conditions and the mix with an increased proportion of big leaved species. The total cover of the plots was mainly dependent on the cover of two species: Sedum album (L.) and Sedum acre (L.). Few species managed to establish spontaneously but the establishment of woody species highlighted the need for proper maintenance.