Shield defense of a larval tortoise beetle

Larvae of the folivorous tortoise beetle, Plagiometriona clavata, carry shields formed from feces and exuviae above their bodies. We used an ecologically relevant predatory ant, Formica subsericea, in a bioassay to determine if shields functioned as simple barriers, as previous studies indicated, or whether they were chemical defenses. Shields were necessary for larval survival; shield removal rendered larvae vulnerable. Shields produced by larvae reared on a substitute diet failed to provide protection. Solvent-leached shields also failed to deter ants, indicating the shield had a host-derived chemical component likely located in the feces, not in the exuviae. Solanum dulcamara, the larval host plant, contained free phytol, steroidal glycoalkaloids, and saponins. Shields contained partially deglycosylated metabolites of host steroidal glycoalkaloids and saponins, a suite of fatty acids, and derivatives of phytol, which together formed a deterrent barrier against ant attack. We compared the mobile shield of P. clavata to the stationary shield of another S. dulcamara-feeding leaf beetle, Lema trilinea. Both larval shield defenses were formed from a very similar array of host-derived compounds with deterrent properties. We concluded that convergent patterns of limited chemical transformation and selective incorporation of particular deterrent metabolites in shield defenses of two unrelated taxa represented responses to selection from invertebrate predators.